The five justices of the court were unanimous in an eight-page decision issued Wednesday afternoon. Duanesburg Democrat Cecilia Tkaczyk brought the case last month, arguing that a Montgomery County judge was wrong in invalidating roughly 450 ballots and certifying Amedore as the winner after a three-week court supervised count.
Fifty-three of those ballots were cast by election workers in Ulster County who filled out and submitted special ballots more than two weeks before Election Day.
The law says election officials may not distribute the ballots more than two weeks before the polls open, which Republicans said should invalidate the votes. (They objected to 39 inspectors’ ballots, compared to 14 objections lodged by Democrats.) The justices, as they suggested during a Monday hearing, said the law only applied to workers at the Board of Elections, and that any voter who submitted a ballot early should be held harmless for a “ministerial error.”
The justices also ordered election officials to open several ballots that were invalidated because not enough information was provided on their application envelope, and several others that were thrown out due to objections on the validity of a voter’s residency.
It was not immediately clear when the ballots would be opened.
It’s also unclear if the ruling will be appealed. Because the decision was unanimous, a “leave” to continue the case before the Court of Appeals must be granted either by the five appellate division justices or the Court of Appeals’ seven judges.
The new senators formally convened Wednesday — without Amedore — and on Tuesday senators met privately in party caucuses to discuss new rules for the chamber that will let the GOP share power with the five-member Independent Democratic Conference.
Amedore was to be the 31st Republican elected to the state Senate, but Brooklyn Democrat Simcha Felder has agreed to vote with the GOP, giving it a voting majority in the 63-seat chamber. Amedore did not vote on Wednesday, though, citing the ongoing appeal.
“I have tremendous respect for the judicial process and despite being certified the winner in this race, I believe that the only appropriate action is to allow the pending legal matter to conclude,” Amedore said in a statement. “This is about governing, not politicizing and I believe some may have attempted to use this day to detract from the critical issues important to all of us. However, I look forward to joining my colleagues in the very near future as I plan to proudly represent the great people of the 46th Senate District.”
His spokesman, Kris Thompson, said the campaign was reviewing the decision. Tkaczyk’s campaign was more buoyant in its reaction.
“We are pleased that the judges of the Appellate Division agree with the very basic principle that ministerial errors should not invalidate New Yorkers’ rights to have their voices heard,” Tkaczyk spokesman Gary Ginsburg said in a statement. “Though many of the ballots were ruled valid, there are still New Yorkers who participated in this election who have not had their votes counted. We respect the judicial process and look forward to a speedy resolution to ensure that the residents of the 46th Senate District have their elected representative seated in the State Senate.”
The five-judge panel, drawn from justices in the Third Department of the state’s Appellate Division, was comprised of three Democrats and two Republicans.
Amedore and Tkaczyk are vying to represent the 46th State Senate District, which stretches from Amsterdam to Kingston through Montgomery, Schenectady, Albany, Greene and Ulster counties.